< Agent Blog
Oct
10
,
2022

Highmark Achieves 5-Star Plan Ratings for 2023

October 10, 2022

Highmark Achieves 5-Star Plan Ratings for 2023

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) recently announced Highmark’s 2023 Star Ratings for Pennsylvania, West Virginia, and New York Medicare Advantage (MA) plans. Highmark's scores were strong again this year, with most plans achieving a 5-Star Rating –the highest score possible!

Pennsylvania HMO: 5 Stars
Pennsylvania PPO: 5 Stars

Highmark’s Community Blue  Medicare HMO & PPO, Complete Blue PPO, Freedom Blue PPO, and Security  Blue HMO-POS MA plans have again achieved the highest possible quality rating  from CMS. These plans achieved 5 out of 5  Stars for the second consecutive year!  

West Virginia PPO: 5 Stars
Highmark’s Medicare  Advantage Freedom Blue PPO plans were scored by CMS and scored a 5 out of 5  stars for the first time. We are the only  Direct Pay 5-Star product offering in West Virginia for 2023!
    

 

Western and Northeastern New York PPO: 5 Stars                                                                                  
Western and Northeastern New York HMO: 4 Stars                                                                                          
In Western and Northeastern New York, Highmark’s MA PPO plans were scored by CMS and scored 5  out of 5 stars for the third year in a row! Highmark’s MA  Health Maintenance Organization (HMO) plans were also scored by CMS and scored 4 out 5 stars.  

 

   
What about Delaware?  

Star Ratings are not on a typical one-year planning cycle, where what we do this year impacts next  year.  Instead, the annual Star Ratings reflect performance from two  years prior. How we performed in calendar year 2021 was used by CMS for our  2023 star ratings. Highmark Delaware's Medicare Advantage plans were launched  in 2022, and therefore have not been rated yet.

 

 

5-Star Special  Enrollment Period

  • If a Medicare Advantage Plan, Medicare drug plan, or Medicare Cost Plan with a 5-star rating becomes available, MA members can use the 5-star Special Enrollment Period to switch from their current Medicare plan to a Medicare plan with a “5-star” quality rating. Members can use this Special Enrollment Period only once between December 8 and November 30.
  • If a MA member moves from a Medicare Advantage Plan that includes prescription drug coverage to a stand-alone Medicare Prescription Drug Plan, they will be disenrolled from their Medicare Advantage Plan, including the health benefit. They will be returned to Original Medicare for coverage of their health services. Members can only switch to a 5-star Medicare Prescription Drug Plan if one is available in their area.
  • If a MA Member moves from a Medicare Advantage Plan that has drug coverage to a 5‑star Medicare Advantage Plan that doesn’t, they may lose your prescription drug coverage. They’ll have to wait until their next       enrollment opportunity to get drug coverage, and they may have to pay a Part D late enrollment penalty.

View Details >View Details >

Questions? Call us at 855-888-8326.

Don't have a MedicareValue page yet?

Get Your FREE Site >

Posts you may be interested in...

Read More

Meet your California Broker Channel Manager: Sandy Wang

December 12, 2025
Agent Blog Icon - Indicates this is a blog article.

Meet your new Broker Channel Manager in California!

Read More

New business technology is on the way for brokers!

December 8, 2025
Agent Blog Icon - Indicates this is a blog article.

These changes include a new contracting system for all brokers/agents, and a new commissions experience for MA/PDP users.

Read More

Highmark Important Updates: Medigap, SSBCI, and Delaware D-SNP Information

December 3, 2025
Agent Blog Icon - Indicates this is a blog article.

Medigap, SSBCI, and Delaware D-SNP Information

Read More

Extend Your Molina Selling Season to December 31!

December 2, 2025
Agent Blog Icon - Indicates this is a blog article.

AEP is coming to a close, but the Integrated Care SEP* can still be used

Read More

UnitedHealthcare: JarvisWRAP for December 1

December 1, 2025
Agent Blog Icon - Indicates this is a blog article.

AEP support, UCard shipments and SSBCI verification

Read More

Cigna Broker Insights: November 2025 - Edition 11.2

November 24, 2025
Agent Blog Icon - Indicates this is a blog article.

Broker Insights: The newsletter for all Medicare brokers - 11.2

Who we are & what we do.

Choosing an FMO to work with is not just about having access to top insurance products and commissions, it’s about finding a one-on-one agent service that is prepared to meet your needs.  

Get to know us, and see how we can help you take your business to the next level.

Learn More

Helpful Links

New Here?

We love meeting new people! Fill out the form below, and one of our sales directors will get in touch with you shortly.

Thank you! Your form has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form